Slouching Towards South Carolina

Oh South Carolina…how I wish, as a native son, I could be proud to claim you as my home. How beautiful it would be to stand tall together and eschew our crippled slouch towards a Bethlehem long bereft of meaning. Can you not, dear sister, hear the mellifluous song of progress and equality in the distant valley, faint at first, but growing louder and more sonorous with each passing day? Did you fail to discern your estranged uncle, History, penning your heedless words and acts for our child? Do you remember what we named her? Do you remember?

My sweet Carolina, your intransigent literality feels like dust and aching bones; it is the slow decay rotting the fecund magnolia of modernity before she fully blossoms; the cross and the selective application; the judgment without the compassion; the liberty but not the freedom. Where did you lose your good friend, Humor? Was he unable to escape that antediluvian midnight from which only few found the dawn? What about his brother, Empathy? I heard he was last seen on the savage road to the plantation centuries ago? Do you remember what we named our child? We named her Tomorrow, and she renounces us every day. Do you remember?

Recent events in South Carolina are troubling. First, the state budget committee led by Rep. Garry Smith, revoked the exact amount of funds two state colleges spent on books by gay authors. Now, legislators have placed pressure on one of the colleges, the University of South Carolina Upstate, to cancel a play by Leigh Hendrix entitled, “How to Be a Lesbian in 10 Days or Less”, which she was invited to perform as part of a symposium on gay topics this month. It seems our politicians are afraid that the play is a literal “How To” for those interested in the fast track to lesbianism.

Had even the slightest amount of research been done, our politicians- and a handful of conservative “journalists” who (sword and shield in hand) are always prepared to battle the pervasive evil of unopposed liberalism indoctrinating our youth- would have learned that Hendrix’s “lecture” is really just a one-person play. It is a comedic, satirical, intelligent, thoughtful, honest, and (most importantly) theatrical performance. The title is ironic, as are the portions of the show that “teach” audience members how to be gay. But as is the case with most things deemed “political” in South Carolina, black and white are the only colors in our palette, and irony and humor are nowhere to be found. How daft can these people actually be? One cannot be taught to be gay. And if one claims that they were, then it’s highly likely they are a charlatan. Being gay is not like adapting a core philosophy or set of principles. It is innate, and no more the product of choice or persuasion than our impulse to breath.

The broader issue in these cases concerns the role government should be playing in our institutions of higher learning. Colleges are pillars of knowledge, opinion, and debate; they are havens for dissent and diversity, and it is unacceptable for government officials to punish them for symposiums, course discussions, or literature chosen by their faculties. Homosexual equality is the civil rights issue of our generation, and is as pertinent to our national and international dialogue on ethics, morality, and liberty as any other enduring struggle. It’s intellectually dishonest and demeaning to students, to suggest that the topic is too incendiary or- in the words of Sen. Kevin Bryant- “perverted”, for college freshmen.

South Carolina’s conservative politicians, who often espouse principles of limited government, see no discrepancy when they argue that it is the responsibility of government to be the arbiters of taste in college classrooms. They, especially under liberal administrations, pride themselves on being seen as iconoclasts who unabashedly differentiate between the efficacy of government programs and the idealism behind them. And yet they are failing to see how coercing college conformity is the antithesis of an unobtrusive government. Without the slightest sense of irony, they are doing exactly what myriad Republicans accuse Democrats of doing in perpetuity: legislating emotionally.

What if it were religious liberty that the government was infringing on? What if our politicians were telling adherents what was acceptable to preach and believe? What if they were canceling guest ministers because they didn’t observe what the government says religion ought to be? I have no doubt that there would be a call to arms. And those leading the way would be right to do so. What’s the difference when it comes to education?

Literature, symposiums, and theater, are what all art and discussion is: a personal expression of experience that strives to make sense of who we are, why we are here, what life means, and how we collectively relate to one another. Reconciling these inquiries with our nature is how we learn to understand. And part of that process stems from our voluntary and involuntary collisions with perspectives that challenge our beliefs, attitudes, and prejudices. For many of us, those initial collisions occur in college. This is why it’s imperative that universities remain free to explore the philosophies, ideas, and constructs of every age, including our own. If South Carolina’s government can tell colleges what is and is not beyond the pale; if they can determine what is and is not appropriate on the subject of knowledge; if they can decide which manner of thinking is acceptable; if they can tell students when they are and are not ready to engage the significant issues of our time; what can we reasonably expect them not to control?

Posted in Rants | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Media’s Collective Amnesia Regarding James Clapper

The Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, who admitted to lying to the National Committee of Intelligence last year about the scope of domestic NSA data collection, has recently testified in front of Congress, claiming that the information provided by Edward Snowden- and reported on by myriad journalists- is providing terrorists with valuable information they are using to change their methods of communication and action. He provides no evidence for this, and in spite of his proven willingness to lie in order to insulate the narrative, members of the media are acting as if his word is irreproachable.

It’s important to note that throughout recorded human history, any time a government has needed to create support for a policy, manipulate public perception of an enemy, or rationalize an action, it has almost always resorted to fear. This fear can be real or imagined, it doesn’t actually matter. As long as the populace believes that with these policies and actions- no matter how much they might infringe upon their personal liberty- they will be safe from the source of their fear, the exploitation of that fear will require minimal to no evidence. Machiavelli wrote about this extensively. Hobbes underscores it in The Leviathan, when he engages the dynamic between the Sovereign, its people, and what reasonable ratio of freedom to security the people can expect. The Founders also remarked on the danger of governance by evocation of fear, warning that there is no greater threat to liberty, than when the government uses an ambiguous fear as a means to gain more power. It is a timeless method of control, designed to receive tacit approval for suspect policies that usually involve a shrinking of liberties that the masses always appear willing to relinquish when their worst fears are summoned.

In our modern world, the fear most exploited, is terrorism. Our government has declared a War on Terror, perpetual by design and illimitable in scope, that has no borders, and whose enemy is stateless, landless, and timeless. The irony is that many of the means we invoke to extirpate this boundless concept, does the opposite. We seek to expunge the recurring threat not by means of diplomacy, education, peace or refraining from intervening in the affairs of sovereign nations, but by matching violence with violence. Thus, as our government disdains the ideological rationale of the enemy, it enacts policies that ensure only the continuation of the conflict. We would do well to recall this fact when our government argues for the necessity of covert security programs that exist precisely because it does its part to stoke the antagonistic flames of ideological warfare.

Strangely, our media allows someone like Clapper, who has openly lied to Congress about NSA capabilities, to be the unchallenged voice of both the continued necessity of these programs, and the dubious claim that making them public has given terrorists the advantage. The pertinent question here is why Clapper still possesses a job? And why should we believe anything he says? He shouldn’t, and we shouldn’t either. But you cannot convince the establishment press of that. It’s as if they have experienced collective amnesia.

If the Administration insists on allowing Clapper to not only remain employed, but to also be its mouthpiece, then the media must insist on ignoring all unsupported claims regarding the necessity of NSA programs as they currently exist.  It has been the method of this Administration and its predecessor, to vociferously ululate “Terrorism!” any time information is disseminated that reflects negatively on their purported intents and endeavors. It is a battle hardened political tactic that the media must counter so that more liberties are not voluntarily forfeited under a false premise of security. Yes terrorism is real, and yes we should expect our government to do what they can to protect our borders, but little evidence has been produced proving the efficacy of these programs, relative to their encroachment on the personal communications of millions of innocent civilians. Until the government can justify such intrusion, and show their commitment to earnestly engaging the debate between privacy and security, the people (and our media) should not fall victim to our fear.

Posted in Rants | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Glenn Greenwald: Our First Amendment Barometer

Glenn Greenwald is the intrepid journalist that was contacted by Edward Snowden last summer to disclose the fact that the NSA is accessing large swaths of data- from within the US and without- by harvesting massive amounts of information shared by civilians via electronic communication. Since first revealing this controversial information, which he ascertained from a multitude of classified documents stolen by Snowden while he was a contractor working inside of the NSA, Greenwald has remained outside the US, where he lives with his husband in Rio de janeiro, Brazil. They have lived in Rio for a number of years, primarily because the Brazilian government recognizes their marriage, but Greenwald used to visit the US regularly to do TV appearances and speaking engagements. As a result of his aforementioned revelations, most of which came while he was a journalist for the US division of The Guardian, he has been reluctant to travel internationally because he believes that the US government would seize the opportunity to arrest him for what they allege are illegal exposures of covert practices that are central to thwarting terrorism.

This week, Greenwald said that he would be looking to travel to the US in the near future to see members of his family, but also because he believes in the constitutional protection afforded to journalists in the First Amendment. He believes that a journalist should speak truth to power, and that a government with a First Amendment should not act belligerently towards those who seek to edify the electorate. Greenwald told Salon’s Brian Beutler,

“My parents are getting older, my nieces [live in the United States] — none of that is something I’m going to go home for now…. I had a foundation that wanted to sponsor and pay for and market aggressively a six-city speaking tour to talk about the NSA story and the revelations. I would have completely loved to have done it… on the assurance that nothing would happen. And because we couldn’t get it from the U.S. government, I had to cancel…I take more seriously the Constitution’s guarantee of a free press in the First Amendment,” he said at the time. “So I have every intention of entering the U.S. as soon as my schedule permits and there’s a reason to do so.” Today he remains defiant — “I’m going to go back to the U.S. for many reasons, but just the fucking principle is enough…. On principle I’m going to force the issue.”

It’s important that we do not overlook the fact that Glenn Greenwald, who is a US citizen, and more importantly, a journalist that has not been convicted of a crime, has to seek assurances from his own government that he will not be arrested if he travels to see his family. And what’s even more significant is that his government is unwilling to give him any such guarantee.

It’s no secret the way the power structure works in this country. The journalists who gain access to the sphere of influence are those who behave most obsequiously. They are the men and women who succumb to the enticing narcotic of power, the effect of which is achieved by eschewing peripheral connections and gaining entrance to the capital. They manage this, not by a desire to create an informed citizenry, but by a willingness to be a subservient stenographer, conveying the message of the government without the slightest adversarial inflection. Journalists that are connected to powerful government officials land exclusive nationally televised interviews, and get invited to dinners hosted by Washington’s elite, therefore the inclination to create friction is quite literally one that does not pay.

This is why Greenwald will not receive assurances that he won’t be detained if he travels to the US. He represents everything that the establishment media is not: a merciless glutton for truth, with an acerbic pen (and tongue) that is as nonpartisan as it is dedicated to upholding the ideal of a free press. Greenwald comes from the Noam Chomskyian school of thought, which is that the basic function of the media is to act as a check and balance to one’s government. He strives to elucidate the subtle yet tireless efforts by the government to obscure the true intentions and actions of entities like the NSA, because he understands that powerful people, unfettered to institutional or public oversight, will act recklessly in the name of power preservation, all while proclaiming that their intent is altruistic. That is unless there is a sovereign estate that can expose this desired omnipotence.  

The struggle today is that the world has become increasingly oligarchical. Corporations infect governments more and more transparently, and the press has become less independent as a result. The need to satisfy advertisers, which generates revenue for the corporations that own most major media outlets, has become more imperative than discerning what’s real. The information we now receive has been manipulated and diluted to the point where what we often encounter is at best a reaffirmation of established beliefs, but quite often strays into the arenas of misinformation, propaganda, and outright fiction. The age of sensationalist media, where entire networks have been constructed to deliver partisan ideology, has erected additional partitions to understanding. The goal is to distract, and to create distrust in the “other” camp. There is no perceived benefit to an informed viewership.

The Obama Administration has nourished this misguided media environment, by seeking to prosecute more journalists and whistleblowers than all other administrations combined. They have artfully devised a double standard for leaking, by aggressively threatening journalists and whistleblowers who reveal information damaging to the administration’s credibility, while making allowances for leaks that do the opposite. There have been a myriad of high level government officials that have leaked favorable information for the administration, without the slightest rebuke. There isn’t anything novel in this tactic of course, all administrations do this. But this level of equivocation, where dissident journalists are punished and persecuted, is an egregious affront to the democratic ideals of free speech and a free press.

This is what makes Glenn Greenwald essential in today’s political climate. This is why it is so important to mark what happens if he does attempt to enter the country. What he disclosed, thanks to Edward Snowden’s conscientious actions, is information that the public deserves to know. The degree to which these secretive programs obstruct future terrorist attacks remains crepuscular, but the debate for what kind of country we want to live in, and how these programs align with a constitutional republic, is one that we can only engage in if we know about them. Thanks to journalists like Greenwald this debate has been facilitated. And yet, because these disclosures reflect negatively on Obama’s Administration, Greenwald is being vaguely threatened for doing his due diligence.

Greenwald articulates an incommodious truth: that government everywhere is inherently opaque, and that it is the function of journalists to illuminate that dusky assembly. When a government threatens to punish one of its citizens and journalists for acting in the public good, it’s an ominous sign for the health of liberty. So rarely does one person act as the barometer for the state of something like the First Amendment. Glenn Greenwald is that person right now, and we should all be paying attention.

Posted in Rants | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Revisiting the Founders

Today being the 4th of July I’ve decided to post various quotes of the Founding Fathers regarding liberty, privacy, and the necessary protections created to guard against the supposed “good intentions” of government. I think the following words are as valid today, as when they were stated over two centuries ago, and it’s good to remind ourselves from time to time of the ideals this country was founded on.

“I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it.”
— Thomas Jefferson

“Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.”
— Benjamin Franklin

“… rightful liberty is unobstructed action according to our own will within limits drawn around us by the equal rights of others. I do not add ‘within the limits of the law,’ because law is often but the tyrant’s will, and always so when it violates the right of an individual”
— Thomas Jefferson

“I believe there are more instances of the abridgment of freedoms of the people by gradual and silent encroachment of those in power than by violent and sudden usurpations.”
— James Madison

“All men having power ought to be distrusted to a certain degree.”
– James Madison

“Power always thinks… that it is doing God’s service when it is violating all his laws.”
– John Adams

“There is danger from all men. The only maxim of a free government ought to be to trust no man living with power to endanger the public liberty.”
– John Adams

“Liberty cannot be preserved without general knowledge among the people.”
– John Adams

“A wise and frugal Government, which shall restrain men from injuring one another, which shall leave them otherwise free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned. This is the sum of good government, and this is necessary to close the circle of our felicities.”
– Thomas Jefferson

“Experience hath shewn, that even under the best forms of government those entrusted with power have, in time, and by slow operations, perverted it into tyranny.”
– Thomas Jefferson

“If Tyranny and Oppression come to this land, it will be in the guise of fighting a foreign enemy.”
– James Madison

“Where an excess of power prevails, property of no sort is duly respected. No man is safe in his opinions, his person, his faculties, or his possessions.”
– James Madison

“No nation could preserve its freedom in the midst of continual warfare.”
– James Madison

“It is a universal truth that the loss of liberty at home is to be charged to the provisions against danger, real or pretended, from abroad.”
– James Madison

“He that would make his own liberty secure, must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty, he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself.”
– Thomas Paine

“He that rebels against reason is a real rebel, but he that in defence of reason rebels against tyranny has a better title to Defender of the Faith, than George the Third.”
– Thomas Paine

“Constitutions should consist only of general provisions; the reason is that they must necessarily be permanent, and that they cannot calculate for the possible change of things.”
– Alexander Hamilton

“Guard against the impostures of pretended patriotism.”
– George Washington

“It will be found an unjust and unwise jealousy to deprive a man of his natural liberty upon the supposition he may abuse it.”
– George Washington

And finally… arguably the most subversive, progressive, and inimitable document in the history of the world: The Declaration of Independence.

“IN CONGRESS, July 4, 1776.

The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America,

When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.–That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, –That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.–Such has been the patient sufferance of these Colonies; and such is now the necessity which constrains them to alter their former Systems of Government. The history of the present King of Great Britain is a history of repeated injuries and usurpations, all having in direct object the establishment of an absolute Tyranny over these States. To prove this, let Facts be submitted to a candid world.

He has refused his Assent to Laws, the most wholesome and necessary for the public good.
He has forbidden his Governors to pass Laws of immediate and pressing importance, unless suspended in their operation till his Assent should be obtained; and when so suspended, he has utterly neglected to attend to them.
He has refused to pass other Laws for the accommodation of large districts of people, unless those people would relinquish the right of Representation in the Legislature, a right inestimable to them and formidable to tyrants only.
He has called together legislative bodies at places unusual, uncomfortable, and distant from the depository of their public Records, for the sole purpose of fatiguing them into compliance with his measures.
He has dissolved Representative Houses repeatedly, for opposing with manly firmness his invasions on the rights of the people.
He has refused for a long time, after such dissolutions, to cause others to be elected; whereby the Legislative powers, incapable of Annihilation, have returned to the People at large for their exercise; the State remaining in the mean time exposed to all the dangers of invasion from without, and convulsions within.
He has endeavoured to prevent the population of these States; for that purpose obstructing the Laws for Naturalization of Foreigners; refusing to pass others to encourage their migrations hither, and raising the conditions of new Appropriations of Lands.
He has obstructed the Administration of Justice, by refusing his Assent to Laws for establishing Judiciary powers.
He has made Judges dependent on his Will alone, for the tenure of their offices, and the amount and payment of their salaries.
He has erected a multitude of New Offices, and sent hither swarms of Officers to harass our people, and eat out their substance.
He has kept among us, in times of peace, Standing Armies without the Consent of our legislatures.
He has affected to render the Military independent of and superior to the Civil power.
He has combined with others to subject us to a jurisdiction foreign to our constitution, and unacknowledged by our laws; giving his Assent to their Acts of pretended Legislation:
For Quartering large bodies of armed troops among us:
For protecting them, by a mock Trial, from punishment for any Murders which they should commit on the Inhabitants of these States:
For cutting off our Trade with all parts of the world:
For imposing Taxes on us without our Consent:
For depriving us in many cases, of the benefits of Trial by Jury:
For transporting us beyond Seas to be tried for pretended offences
For abolishing the free System of English Laws in a neighbouring Province, establishing therein an Arbitrary government, and enlarging its Boundaries so as to render it at once an example and fit instrument for introducing the same absolute rule into these Colonies:
For taking away our Charters, abolishing our most valuable Laws, and altering fundamentally the Forms of our Governments:
For suspending our own Legislatures, and declaring themselves invested with power to legislate for us in all cases whatsoever.
He has abdicated Government here, by declaring us out of his Protection and waging War against us.
He has plundered our seas, ravaged our Coasts, burnt our towns, and destroyed the lives of our people.
He is at this time transporting large Armies of foreign Mercenaries to compleat the works of death, desolation and tyranny, already begun with circumstances of Cruelty & perfidy scarcely paralleled in the most barbarous ages, and totally unworthy the Head of a civilized nation.
He has constrained our fellow Citizens taken Captive on the high Seas to bear Arms against their Country, to become the executioners of their friends and Brethren, or to fall themselves by their Hands.
He has excited domestic insurrections amongst us, and has endeavoured to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian Savages, whose known rule of warfare, is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.

In every stage of these Oppressions We have Petitioned for Redress in the most humble terms: Our repeated Petitions have been answered only by repeated injury. A Prince whose character is thus marked by every act which may define a Tyrant, is unfit to be the ruler of a free people.

Nor have We been wanting in attentions to our British brethren. We have warned them from time to time of attempts by their legislature to extend an unwarrantable jurisdiction over us. We have reminded them of the circumstances of our emigration and settlement here. We have appealed to their native justice and magnanimity, and we have conjured them by the ties of our common kindred to disavow these usurpations, which, would inevitably interrupt our connections and correspondence. They too have been deaf to the voice of justice and of consanguinity. We must, therefore, acquiesce in the necessity, which denounces our Separation, and hold them, as we hold the rest of mankind, Enemies in War, in Peace Friends.

We, therefore, the Representatives of the united States of America, in General Congress, Assembled, appealing to the Supreme Judge of the world for the rectitude of our intentions, do, in the Name, and by Authority of the good People of these Colonies, solemnly publish and declare, That these United Colonies are, and of Right ought to be Free and Independent States; that they are Absolved from all Allegiance to the British Crown, and that all political connection between them and the State of Great Britain, is and ought to be totally dissolved; and that as Free and Independent States, they have full Power to levy War, conclude Peace, contract Alliances, establish Commerce, and to do all other Acts and Things which Independent States may of right do. And for the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor.”

Posted in Food For Thought | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

A Plea to Senators Wyden and Udall: Become Whistleblowers

Senators Ron Wyden and Mark Udall have been outspoken critics of the recently revealed NSA surveillance programs for some time now. In fact, with few exceptions, they’ve been the only real critics of these secret programs within our entire government. While their willingness to vocalize their concerns is commendable, their criticism has been largely reduced to vague and cryptic sound bites. According to them, the information in question is classified and it’s illegal to publicly acknowledge the details. In lieu of explicit commentary on what they believe to be an egregious abuse of power, they have chosen instead to say what they can, when they can, without actually “breaking the law”.

In the wake of Edward Snowden’s disclosures, they have continued to ambiguously proclaim that what the public has learned is just the fringe, and that some of the statements the NSA have released in an effort to clarify its parameters and limitations are blatantly spurious. In spite of these remarks, the Senators continue to practice restraint, claiming they aren’t permitted to unequivocally decry the statements and programs because it would be criminal to expose them.

I am calling on Senators Wyden and Udall to dissent and openly criticize the government and NSA, with full disclosures concerning what they know about how these programs operate, and the ways in which the government has obscured the truth. It’s easy for me to espouse courage and justice in this scenario, that’s true; I’m ignorant of what these men know and am not threatened by the consequences of exposing classified secrets. I fully acknowledge the difference of opinion I might have if I was in their shoes. But in the interest of indulging this fiction, I’ll simply state that this is no time for pusillanimity.

Consider for a moment the power that revelations of government abuse- illuminated by Congressmen who sit on the Senate Intelligence Committee- would have. Think about the uproar that would ensue, if in fact Wyden and Udall became whistleblowers. They would unquestionably become the most prominent expositors of government malfeasance in US history. Currently, they’ve been relegated to infrequent enigmatic declarations warning of an indiscernible breach of trust. But the breadth of the overreach remains opaque. Pertinacity is needed by those who possess the facts. Acts of conscience must be accompanied with the temerity necessary to endure the demonization efforts of the government and media that are inevitable.

Do we not deserve to know exactly what the scope and scale of the government’s capabilities are? Shouldn’t the debate about privacy and security be transparent, so that we may have a share in how our lives are monitored? What right does Wyden, Udall, or any other government official have, to withhold this information from those who have elected them? They’d shout “National Security” or that we need to protect ourselves from “The Terrorists”, but these are just stock responses, spewed thoughtlessly by government officials when they run out of ground to give. It’s the political equivalent of telling your children not to do something because you “said so”.

At the risk of sounding melodramatic, I’ll simply ask Senators Wyden and Udall: who do you stand with? Is it the government and their secrets, or the American people? Wyden and Udall swore to uphold the Constitution; but what if the government is subverting the ideals within? What if it is the NSA that is behaving unconstitutionally? Does that not mean that it is the government- not Wyden and Udall- that has betrayed its oath? What logic can be spun to justify the continued silence of these Senators, if in fact the government is perverting the Constitution?

This is what distinguishes genuine whistleblowers like Daniel Ellsberg, Bradley Manning, Thomas Drake, and Edward Snowden: the consequences of inaction frightened them more than what would result from civil disobedient acts of conscience. In all of the aforementioned cases, these men were willing to risk everything, and did. In the cases of Manning and Snowden, we don’t quite know how their stories will end. What we do know is that they are unflinchingly courageous, and that their integrity- which sells for so little in politics- is something our government officials should aspire to. I think Senators Wyden and Udall have a unique opportunity to make history for the right reasons. They should seize it.

Posted in Food For Thought | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 39 Comments

Heaven: Are Atheists Welcome?

A couple of weeks ago Pope Francis stated during the homily of his morning mass that all people, even atheists, can ascend to heaven if they fulfill their duty to do good. “Just do good and we’ll find a meeting point.” he said. The tolerance and embracement implied in his comments are a departure from his predecessor, Benedict, who took a more conservative and narrow stance on people outside the Catholic faith. Francis’ words were interpreted by believers and non-believers alike as a positive sign for the future of the Church, insofar as it seemed to discard some of the more intransigent and exclusory rhetoric of times past.

Unsurprisingly, just a week after Francis’ benevolent remarks, Rev. Thomas Rosica, a Vatican spokesperson, countered the Pope’s inclusion of non-Catholics and non-believers by saying:“All salvation comes from Christ, the Head, through the Church which is his body. Hence they cannot be saved who, knowing the Church as founded by Christ and necessary for salvation, would refuse to enter her or remain in her.”

Or perhaps more tersely: “Just what do you think you’re doing, Holiness? Atheists are bound for the inferno!”

So much for infallibility.

The politics are discernible. The Holy Mother Church doesn’t want the head of Christendom telling the faithful that they can circumvent the collection plate and still attain salvation. This isn’t about atheists, this is about remaining relevant. Even still, I find this exchange amusing for myriad reasons.

I’d give just about anything to be a fly on a Vatican wall, listening to the Pope and his minions debate, without irony, which fellow humans are eligible for “saving”. The thought of old men audaciously deliberating the after-life destination of us all, is something I find great humor in pondering; especially when they’re willing to overlook the majority of the world’s population because they are “willfully evading Catholic dogma” as the Vatican statement implies. This means that people born into Muslim, Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, Protestant, and irreligious cultures and families- if cognizant of the Catholic Church- are at odds with God and therefore cannot enter heaven, unless they convert. So if you’re a Sunni Muslim in Bahrain and you’re introduced to Catholicism by learning of the Crusades, you’re expected to understand that the Church is the one true path to God, and that if you do not become a Catholic you cannot be saved. Perfectly reasonable right? Just abandon your entire cultural heritage and everything you’ve ever known, and all is well. No big deal.

What are these men even debating?

If you think about it, they are arguing over a fairy land. And not whether that fairly land exists, and if so, what evidence we have to reinforce that claim, no. They are asserting this fairy land definitely exists, and that they also can determine who can travel there and how the path is properly traversed. This is akin to someone telling you that Zeus and Apollo are real and that they not only know where Mt. Olympus is, but if you believe what they say, they can guide you there. Just how credulous do they think we are? Pretty goddamn credulous apparently. And guess what? They’re right to think so. Because who would treat claims like this seriously, if these statements were being made outside of religion?

Picture the scene: an all male panel, ensconced in their own self-worth, obstinately quarreling over a fictional place. A FICTIONAL PLACE! Envision them in their flowing robes, many feeling death’s shadow creeping toward them with greater and greater celerity, telling their “truth” like Shakespeare’s idiot, “full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.” And yet even though we all possess the facility to rationally deconstruct these statements in this very way, because it is the Pope, the Vatican, and religion, this divergence is perceived to be meaningful.

The fits of laughter within must be unceasing. At least I hope so. That’s what I’d do if I was involved in the continuation of one of the world’s most enduring cons. But, knowing religion like I do, it’s safe to assume that this fatuous and illusory conflict is being argued with stoic solemnity. These men believe wholeheartedly in the necessity of this debate. Unless of course I’m mistaken, and the aforementioned politics are really what’s driving this internal friction, in which case the front of doctrinal nuance is actually a relief in a strange way. If nothing else it would mean they are aware of just how absurd this narrative really is.

As an atheist, I want to know! Which is it? Papal advocacy for my heavenly inclusion, or am I destined for an eternity in the underworld? Patience is a gift I’ve never received but I suppose I’ll have to endure the suspense.

I like to think they have agreed to settle this argument with an epic game of Papal Guitar Hero, and the Pope encores with “Stairway to Heaven” for the win. But then all of the Cardinals get upset because he didn’t check his infallibility at the door, which the rules demand. That’s clearly cheating. “Damn it!” the Pope says. “Oh well, more room for us.” And the room erupts with laughter.

Posted in Food For Thought | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 8 Comments

Addendum to Aren’t Religion and Politics both to Blame for the War on Terror

Thanks to Glenn Greenwald sharing my piece in one of his recent columns, I’ve received a lot of thoughtful insight, critiques, and opinions from a variety of readers, concerning my analysis of the “Terrorism Debate” that he, Murtaza Hussain, Sam Harris and Andrew Sullivan have been engaged in of late. One recurring criticism however has kind of bothered me and I wanted to explicitly address it here.

Setting aside the fact that I expressly covered the issue of free expression, and the significance that lies in being able to openly discuss, debate, challenge, criticize and even ridicule every manner of political, philosophical, ideological, and religious thought, I have been told by a number of commentators that:

Bad ideas should be able to be criticized without reverting to labels of racism or Islamophobia.

I couldn’t agree more. But there are two assumptions to be made here.

1.) These readers obviously did not read the entirety of my piece, and at some point decided to abandon the effort, choosing instead to assume the remainder.

2.) They are also confusing my analysis with the origin of this debate, pertaining to the labeling of Sam Harris and other “New Atheists” as racist Islamophobes who clearly have an axe to grind with Islam.

On this first point I argue in my piece that Greenwald and company don’t often tackle the issue of free expression when it comes to Middle Eastern countries and fundamentalist Islam. Religion, like all man-made constructs, should not be immune to debate, criticism and ridicule. In short, the right to worship and express ideas of a religious tenor- no matter how infantile they are- is sacrosanct. The ideas and the philosophies themselves are not.

For example not long ago Richard Dawkins ridiculed journalist Mehdi Hasan’s belief in the literal possibility of the Prophet ascending to heaven on a winged horse. Hasan essentially stated that, as a Muslim, he believes in the possibility of miracles. Dawkins’ argument was that because Hasan admitted to this belief, his journalistic credibility should suffer. The inevitable spin from this exchange cast Dawkins as a bigot and Islamophobe, because in the view of the offended, Dawkins was stating that practicing Muslims can’t make good journalists. In reality, Dawkins was saying that while people have the right to belief and freedom of expression, they do not have the right to keep their beliefs and expressions from being criticized.

Knowing that Hasan believes literally in certain miracles is good for his readership, because it gives them a window into his psyche. No writer is without bias and discerning their belief system is central to understanding the lens with which they see the world. Some of Hasan’s readers might be more skeptical now, when reading certain pieces of his, not because being a Muslim makes him incapable of being a good journalist, but because they might find his credulity insightful to understanding the perspectives he argues in his other work. Dawkins would invariably express similar reservations if a Christian writer admitted to him that he believed in the literal virgin birth. He wasn’t picking on Islam; he was chastising ridiculous ideas that should be criticized.

When Glenn Greenwald ridiculed President Obama for his speech on counter-terrorism, cautioning the reader to treat the president’s lofty rhetoric cynically, he wasn’t suggesting that we do so because Glenn has an aversion to Democrats and thinks they are incapable of being good presidents. He’s implying that we temper our enthusiasm because rarely has Obama’s rhetoric been matched by action. Translation: “This guy has said a lot of great things in the past, but because he has rarely followed them up with action, he hasn’t earned the right to be taken seriously.”

What’s the difference in these two criticisms? I’d argue there isn’t one. Except that one has to do with religion. True, politics can often lead to inflammatory debates. But religion is unique in the level of respect it innately demands for no reason whatsoever. We are a species that irrationally defends all stripes of preposterous claims and ideas, but when it comes to the subject of faith, we defend most zealously that which we know least about. We don’t know if God exists, yet in spite of this we insist on emotionally responding to those who challenge religious belief because we’ve come to revere and respect religion on the basis of what it is, instead of on the substance and merits of what it does, what it claims, and what it can prove. No one would ever allow someone with the platform of Hasan to get away with a dubious/controversial political statement, without questioning his rationale. Why should a similar comment that is religious in nature be any different? I think Greenwald abstains from taking on this double standard, which is wrong, because he’d never allow a politician- or a journalist covering politics- to get away with political statements he knows to be incredible.

On the second point, people like Sam Harris and Richard Dawkins are indispensable precisely because of the way they deconstruct religious belief and its use of unsubstantiated claims to silence voices and actions of dissent. An ineffable sky deity dictates that women aren’t entitled to an education, that homosexuals aren’t equal to heterosexuals, that we should teach our children in science class that we were “intelligently designed”, that winged horses, virgin births, and resurrections from death are real things, and that eternal rewards are reserved for those who strap bombs to their body and kill innocent people along with themselves. These are bad ideas that should be confronted and rebuked, and doing so should not lead to accusations of racism or Islamophobia.

However when someone like Richard Dawkins admits that he’s never read the Quran, that should also be met with ridicule because he has succeeded in discrediting himself rather unwittingly. Can he still have an opinion of Islam? Absolutely. But should those who listen to him perhaps take him less seriously on the subject now that they know he’s never read the book? I would say yes, for precisely the same reasons that he was arguing against the credibility of Hasan.

On the issue of racism and Islamophobia, I’ll simply state that I chose to abstain from addressing those claims in my piece because quite frankly I find the argument irrelevant. Perhaps my atheism makes me biased, but I’m not convinced that these men are racists simply because they stridently criticize an ideology. Islam is not a race after all. (Although I will concede that in our modern Western parlance, Islam has become synonomous with “brown and black people from the Middle East.”) I certainly don’t agree with the arguments Harris has made regarding profiling, or his claims that we are explicitly at war with Islam, but the purpose of my piece was not to engage that debate, but to analyze the combination of elements that are driving the perpetual “War on Terror”. I find the religious and political elements to be, as I said in my piece, co-conspirators in a larger geopolitical game which is far more relevant than an argument over whether or not certain members of the intelligentsia are racist or not. That verdict is for others to decide.

Posted in Food For Thought | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 9 Comments

Aren’t Religion and Politics Both to Blame for War on Terror?

Glenn Greenwald, Murtaza Hussain, Andrew Sullivan, Sam Harris, and others have been debating, rather vehemently recently, the subject of terrorism. The primary rift between them is whether or not the violent acts of Muslim extremists are motivated by religion or politics. In my opinion both are integral and it’s dishonest to pretend differently.

Greenwald and Hussain are of the opinion that- as stated almost universally by each suspected terrorist from 9/11 to the Boston Marathon– Western foreign policy, with its brutal occupations, bombings, drone campaigns, and propping up of oppressive dictators, is actively creating more, not less, of the very thing the “War on Terror” is designed to extirpate: the threat terrorism. Their argument is that it is naive to believe that Western actions do not play a significant role in the blowback we experience in the form of terrorist attacks on Western soil. For them, the simple logic of cause and effect is our guide: If you indiscriminately target citizens and support regimes that kill innocent people in other countries, for the sake of national interests, all while citing “freedom and democracy” as justification for being there, you should not be surprised if retaliation is sought. Greenwald and company do not justify that retaliation, as some of their critics have wrongly asserted. They are merely underlining a rational set of reasons for “why they hate us”, in an effort to counter the “they hate us for our freedoms” narrative that is often force-fed to Western citizens by their governments.

Sullivan and company would disagree about Western militaries indiscriminately targeting civilians. They would suggest that this is where the fundamental distinction between “us and them” lies. We do not purposefully seek to kill innocent civilians when we attack. They do. I’m not convinced this is entirely true. I think both sides are guilty of this motivation. The difference of opinion here is where the ambiguity of the word terrorism is most apparent.

Greenwald finds the word “terrorism” devoid of meaning, stating that it has been euphemistically hijacked and is never applied consistently. He believes that the use of the word is entirely dependent on who the violent actor is. If it’s a Muslim person or entity, and is directed toward the West, the violence is unquestionably labeled terrorism. If the act is committed by a Western nation or entity, different standards within the media and intelligentsia apply. Therefore the violence perpetuated by the West is rarely dealt with honestly. Any attempt at drawing a parallel, or merely questioning if certain Western aggression should be called terror, invites the harshest hyperbolic condemnation from critics, causing genuine efforts to engage the substance of the debate to flounder. This lack of consistency renders the word, in Greenwald’s opinion, meaningless.

His critics seem to disagree. In their view the distinction between what the West has done, and what radical Islam strives to do, is clear. The Fundamental difference, in someone like Sullivan’s mind, is intent. If this is true, then aren’t we guilty of a biased postulation that “our” intent is always noble, and “theirs” is not? Are we even capable of judging this impartially? And doesn’t it betray a certain nationalistic hubris to argue in this way? If the intent is to coerce a populace by means of fear, in order to achieve a political end, it’s hard to look upon Western interventionism honestly and find every instance innocent of that intention. Since I largely agree with Greenwald on this point, I’m not going to penetrate further as I’m more concerned with areas that I think both sides aren’t treating with total veracity.

Andrew Sullivan, Sam Harris, and several other critics, conversely believe that US and Western involvement in the Middle East is not the primary cause of attacks on Western soil. Events like 9/11 and the Boston Marathon, according to them, aren’t as much political as they are religious in nature. Global jihad and the annihilation of the infidel, is the only object on the mind of Islamic extremists that continue to attack the West.

It is their contention that Islam poses a unique threat in the world because currently, it is the only faith that unabashedly incites its followers to violence. They acknowledge the fact that radical Islam is not practiced by the majority of Muslims, but they reject the notion that it is just a fringe movement. They believe that it is not relegated to the periphery, but is instead very much a central doctrine that at present inspires far too many people (and governments) to not only look upon the infidel as a perpetual enemy, but also fellow Muslims and countrymen who adhere to subtle nuances of the faith. The sectarian violence that is currently destroying countries like Iraq and Syria are prime examples of the inflexibility of Islam, and thus, entire swaths of Muslims who share a common nationality are being killed for what Freud once called “The Narcissism of the Small Difference.” For Harris and Sullivan, it is the way fanatical interpretations of any faith seem to justify anything, including violence against innocents, which makes radical Islam especially pernicious.

In spite of the validity of their arguments, I can’t help but detect a willful dishonesty on both sides of this argument in certain places.

How can studious political observers like Harris and Sullivan not think that what Western nations have done, and continue to do, throughout the Middle East, has no bearing on the motivations and actions of those who retaliate? Do they hear captured terrorism suspects when they state that they sought revenge on the West for its sustained occupation of Muslim countries, and think they are being disingenuous? That they are choosing to artfully beguile us into believing that this isn’t about religion? Are we supposed to hear those confessions and forget about them, choosing only to focus on the fact that the attackers scream “Allahu Akbar” as they kill?

I’m equally confused by Harris and Sullivan’s willingness, at times, to overlook the circular nature of this conflict. Whether or not you think US intervention is a force for good, it is shortsighted not to see how our presence in the Middle East creates powerful tools for the recruitment of future radicals. Whether it be sanctions or bombings that kill thousands of Iraqis, indiscriminate drone attacks known as “signature strikes” in places like Yemen, Pakistan, and Somalia, the constant support we grant to some of the most corrupt and repressive regimes in the region (including what is arguably the most fundamentalist of all the Islamic governments, Saudi Arabia), the unwaveringly unilateral support for Israel, or the indefinite detention of Muslims in spite of being cleared for release in places like Guantanamo, these realities are known and used to create and solidify anti-Western sentimentality. You cannot possibly expect for Muslims to learn of these policies, accept them insouciantly, and believe that Western “liberators” have their best interests at heart. This is not a defense or justification for the violence that is committed because of the way the aforementioned realities are exploited. But consider the inverse. How would you expect the US and its allies to react if similar practices were directed towards them?

We know exactly how we would react. The way the US exploited the travesty of 9/11 to justify an egregious attack on a nation that had nothing to do with it, was edifying. Furthermore, the US continued to propagandistically exploit the ensuing fear that followed 9/11, as a way to treat human beings- some of whom we call fellow citizens- as second class citizens. Could you imagine what we’d do if we faced the kind of sustained attacks that Middle Easterners are accustomed to? This is not to say that Islamic extremists don’t exploit potential adherents in much the same way. They most certainly do. Hence the circular nature of this “war”.

It’s strange when someone like Sullivan attempts to cite events like our invasion of Iraq, the support for Afghan radicals against the Soviets, and the financial aid we’ve given to regimes like Egypt, as proof of our benevolence in the region. This is once again his way of trying to define intent. The irony of course is that if you look at Afghanistan in the 1980’s, when we armed warlords and radicals with weapons and money in order to kill Russians, the US chose radical Islam over allowing Communism to gain a major foothold in the region. (This was when Communism, not radical Islam, posed the great existential threat to our nation. This is when the same modern day propaganda being used to inspire fear against Islam, was directed against all things Communist. Exchange radical Islam for Communism in any of the writings of the most ardent supporters for perpetual war at that time, and notice the similarity in language; the constancy of the peril we live under; the perverse evil of the imminent threat we must always be prepared to fight. The fact is radical Islam was seen as the lesser of two evils back then; a necessary risk in order to defeat a larger and more ubiquitous threat. Since the fall of the Soviet Union, the roles have reversed.)

Closer examination of our involvement in the Middle East reveals that we have invariably supported some of the most brutal Islamic fundamentalist regimes in the region, selling many of them arms that they use against their own people who are struggling for democracy. Does Sullivan actually think we care about these citizens? Does he think we are concerned about their civil rights? About their freedom of expression? We shouldn’t pretend our intentions are anything but self-serving. They always have been. Is Islam- in that part of the world- failing to embrace plurality and modernity? Yes. But it seems that millions of Middle Easterners, Muslims and non-Muslims alike, want something different, as the last two years have indicated with the varying success of the Arab Spring.

The question is this: Do the people in these nations suffer more because of the effect that Islamic radicalism has on their governments, or because Western interventionism- with its long history of colonialist imperialism- has installed puppet regimes that care more about profits and power, than they do about governing their people? And are the two ideas- in concert- not equal conspirators in a larger geopolitical game?

The last issue I take with Sullivan and Harris’ side of this argument is the notion that 9/11 is somehow when this conflict began; that we in America were neutral businessmen in the Middle East, when suddenly, for no apparent reason, Islam attacked us. This reeks of historical revisionism. And that history goes both ways. This war is an ancient one, and has been a self-generating conflict for centuries. (At the heart of the conflict was, and maybe still is, religion on both sides. The religiosity from the West has been used- as Greenwald has stated- rather conspicuously in myriad speeches by Western military and government leaders. In not so subtle language they have stressed that this is an ideological war; that it is the duty of all Christians to combat this enemy, and that the wars in the Middle East have as much to do with religious conviction, as they do anything else.)

Greenwald’s larger point is that Western “interventionism” precedes 9/11; that 9/11 was the manifestation of decades of Western injustice in the Middle East, which in turn caused the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan, creating the rationale for subsequent terrorist plots against Western entities ever since. 9/11 was not the beginning of this conflict; it was the continuation of it. Just as the attacks on the Marine barracks in Lebanon and the USS Cole were before it. The war, on both sides, is perpetual by design.

Regardless if you believe “we” are just, and “they” are not, you cannot possibly be acquainted with the realities of this conflict and think that what the West has done in that part of the world, for a very long time, is in no way part of why so many hate us there. Refusal to accept this indicates a blind nationalistic fervor that is just as corruptible as any religion, and is often led by the same irrationality and shunning of evidence that accompanies religious faith.

***

Any cursory examination of the history of Islam reveals that it isn’t an innately evil force or faith. The Quran, much like the Bible before it, suffers from the duality of its message. It bears the mark of the world it was written for. Like other institutions and faiths, it also possesses a rich cultural history that can claim significant discoveries in science, mathematics, poetry, music, art, and literature. But Islam has not experienced a lasting Reformation. It has not endured a period equivalent to what is now known as the Enlightenment in the West, in which free thought and most importantly doubt, was granted free expression. There exists still, horrid discrimination against atheism and other ideas that are antithetical to Islamic fundamentalism, and often times one takes his or her life into their hands if they are courageous enough to dissent. The right to openly deny and question, that which Islam says is absolute, is foreign to many Muslims living in the Middle East.

Christianity used to be this way until it endured a series of gradual changes that forced the religion to evolve. That’s not my way of saying that Christianity is superior to Islam. I’m simply stating that if we use history as our guide, the various movements that softened the ultra-conservatism of Christianity were a positive for millions of human beings, if not immediately, then certainly over time. Similar changes have not occurred on the same scale in Islam. True we shouldn’t expect Islam to follow the same course that Christianity has. There are innumerable external factors that play into this, many of which involve the history of colonialism. But in theory at least, as I’m sure Harris and Sullivan would agree, an introduction of liberalism is badly needed in Middle Eastern Islamic nations. And by this, I’m not implying that this liberalism should come from the West.

I agree with Harris when he asks if a play like the “Book of Mormon” could expect the same peaceful reaction if it were written about Islam? Could such a satire transpire? Would anyone risk undertaking it? These are valid questions. One has to believe that right now, the answer is no. Greenwald, who is as fierce an advocate of the unequivocal necessity for free speech as we currently have in political commentary, knows this better than anyone: that no idea, philosophy, political ideology, or religion, should be exempt from scrutiny, debate, criticism, or ridicule. Islam struggles with this concept internally, let alone with anyone outside the faith, and on questions of expression and the freedom to examine the realities of the religion, it is failing to engage itself thoughtfully and compassionately. (If we’re being honest, US foreign policy is failing in the exact same way.)

This is not to say that all Muslims think this way. There are far too many examples of Muslim scholars, writers, politicians, intellectuals and religious leaders condemning terrorism and espousing freedom of expression, to think this is true. And to insinuate that over a billion people believe free expression should be stifled, or that Islam is at its most authentic when it’s violent, is a gross misrepresentation of the faith. But there is a very real extremist element within that poses a threat- most commonly to other Muslims- and makes the need for self-criticism all the more difficult, but necessary, in 2013.

The question is why? What is it about Islam that makes the extremist element prone to violence on such consistently large scales? And is it really “more dangerous than other faiths”, or is that Western propaganda manipulating our perceptions? Are we not wrong to implicate Islam as a whole? Isn’t it prejudicial to assume that all Muslims think and believe in this way? One might say that Western foreign policy is to blame for why radicalized Islam is so violent. But it’s also Muslims, not Westerners, who suffer most. Is this the result of some inherent evil of the faith? Or is the religiosity merely a front for the political divide that is at the heart of so much Muslim on Muslim violence? I’d never suggest that there isn’t a political underbelly to suicide bombings, but without the credulity of the believer, and his/her unwavering faith in an eternal reward, the entire practice is neutered. Religion has the monopoly on this kind of thinking, and it always has. But unlike some in this argument, I’d include nationalism in that religious-like description. I think it too demands blind faith to the point that it can inspire people to behave irrationally in certain situations; maybe not for divine rewards, but for the mythology of their nation’s “exceptionalism” in the world.

Where we in the West are most often failed, in terms of our perception of Islam, is how it is treated by the media. We very rarely get to hear from moderate Islamic voices in the wake of terrorist attacks, and the primacy of religious extremism is always promoted- often before it’s definitively known if the suspect is even Muslim- and very little to no focus is placed on the political motives that these terrorists proclaim. The vilification of Islam as a whole is undertaken with relative ease for these precise reasons, and the media circumvents every opportunity to critically debate Western interventionism. It simply doesn’t fit the pervasive narrative that our government promotes. Western media obsequiously ignores the political side of this issue, at the government’s bidding, like the good stenographers that they are.

But, there are valid points to be made when talking about fundamentalist governments like Saudi Arabia, and its efforts to thwart free expression and education; the right to talk openly about the good and the bad of any ideology; the right to satirize and have a sense of humor about religion; the right to compare and contrast; the right to ask for evidence when an institution that makes large claims for itself demands that it is the source of truth; the right to challenge the superstitious, by asserting that life in the here and now is far more entitled to respect than any religious interpretation of the hereafter. This is what made the Reformation- and ultimately the Enlightenment- indispensable in the Western world; the freedom to question government and religious institutions, without fear of being deprived of one’s life or liberty.

Greenwald would probably argue that perhaps the vociferation of extremist elements in this debate is a direct consequence of Western aggression and occupation. As I stated above, it’s not unreasonable to suggest that Western involvement in the Middle East has empowered Islamic radicals both intentionally and unintentionally. It’s also plausible to argue that many Western leaders believe in a Christian mission to “tame the savage barbarian” and that aggression is the only way to do so. But isn’t it true that moderate Islam must be more vocal and active throughout the Middle East; that it needs to combat the domineering perception permeating the non-Muslim world that Islam is inherently violent, by first accepting the fact that at present, extremists control the global platform; and that elements of Islam have a problem with modernity, free expression, education, women, freethinkers, and homosexuals? Shouldn’t moderate Islam acknowledge that no idea or institution is beyond reproach and demand that it be the clamoring voice in this discussion?

The West, on the other hand, cannot expect to assuage the threat of terror by using terror. That circular logic has only succeeded in aiding Islamic extremists in gaining support, even from those that don’t condone the ideology. In all of the back and forth between Harris, Sullivan, Hussain, and Greenwald, the question that never gets asked is, what is the US and her allies doing in that part of the world? Why are we really there? The short answer is “national interests”, which is just a euphemism for oil. But the larger issue is more complex, and it is in that complexity that the West must also be honest about what its motivations are and how it can expect perpetual war if it doesn’t change its policies or leave the region. To discern this one needs only to attempt to see from the eyes of the occupied. We once knew that feeling well in this country, just a few centuries ago. Today we’re convinced of our unparalleled amity and of our sincere desire to bring democracy to the world. As many Middle Easterners have stated, the reality on the ground doesn’t jibe with these assertions.

This problem is as old as recorded human history: the struggle for freedom, power, religious liberty, empire, self-governance, expression and equality are constants in our world. Until all of these issues (and the discrepancies within) are dealt with honestly, any hope at constructively addressing radical Islam and Western occupation is futile. I think both sides do a disservice to their positions- and the debate at large- when they refuse to recognize the validity of their opponents’ stronger points. All of these issues play a role in the dilemma of Western and Middle Eastern violence, religiosity, politics, equality, and sovereignty and it’s naïve to suggest otherwise.

In answer to several comments made about this piece, I offer an addendum that can be found here: https://roundersandrogues.wordpress.com/2013/06/03/addendum-to-arent-religion-and-politics-both-to-blame-for-the-war-on-terror/

Follow me on Twitter https://twitter.com/cterryadams

Posted in Food For Thought, Rants | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 112 Comments

Obama’s Hubris: The Drone “Rule Book”

Over the weekend the New York Times reported that President Obama- feeling slightly ambiguous about the election’s outcome- decided that it was imperative that his administration define more clearly, the legal process behind drone strikes, out of a supposed fear that Mitt Romney and the Republican Party could inherit the program.  The underlying theme of the story is that Obama has/had reservations on how poorly defined the opaque program is, and that parameters need to be installed in order to ensure that the appropriate levels of checks and balances are in place.  The implication being, that Republicans would certainly abuse the power to assassinate perceived terrorist threats if left unbridled, while Democrats are innately more responsible at handling the program as is.

The irony of this “concern”, is that Obama has already used this power, and the secrecy it’s wrapped in, to assassinate three American citizens, without trial or open commentary on the matter.  When pressed, they even leaked that the primary American citizen who was targeted, Anwar al-Awlaki, had his constitutional right of due process “satisfied” behind closed doors, conducted by a biased panel of Presidential advisors.  It’s hard to imagine a more egregious abuse of this power.  Yet the illusion of responsibility abounds.

Setting aside the hubris that it takes to issue such a statement- one that obviously was approved to be leaked by the administration- there are a few issues that should be mentioned.

First, it appears that Obama is quite aware of the scrutiny he’s faced regarding drones.  He’s also cognizant of the fact that his administration, claiming to be the most transparent ever, has done much to protect the secrecy of this program- under the premise of national security- which has stifled constructive public discourse.  We know his team has exaggerated- and in some cases completely fabricated– the number of civilian deaths in drone strikes, while also conveniently re-defining the word “militant” to mean “all military-age males in the vicinity of a strike, unless proven otherwise posthumously.”  One gets the impression, that perhaps Obama wanted to clean up something that could negatively impact the legacy of his presidency.

Second, it’s interesting to examine the parallel between religious faith, with the faith of partisans in their political leaders.  Both cases require and encourage, the suspension of reality by way of ignoring evidence and reason.  If a Republican president had used the “Global War on Terror” excuse, to kill American citizens without due process, and continued to indiscriminately bomb Muslim countries with a method known as “Signature Strikes”- which essentially examines behavioral patterns of potential “targets” and kills them without actually knowing their identities- most of the Democrats now supporting Obama, would be outraged.  If Democrats discovered that a Republican president had been bombing funerals and rescuers, in order to assassinate targets they believed were in attendance, they would invariably label such a practice immoral.  They might even go so far as to call that president, a war criminal.  But Obama leads their party;  he’s a former constitutional attorney;  he’s erudite and reads Thomas Aquinas;  he ran on the lofty rhetoric of hope and change, and wants to move the country forward;  he believes in transparency and the judicial process.  It doesn’t matter what he does; that’s irrelevant.  All that matters is what he tells us.

It doesn’t matter that he continues to allow warrantless wiretapping, and protects the NSA at every turn as it continues to collect and store billions of domestic communications every day.  It doesn’t matter that he has continued to indefinitely detain anyone, including American citizens, that he believes is a threat to national security.  It doesn’t matter if those he indefinitely detains, are never actually given a trial.  Nor does it matter if there is ever any evidence proving the imminent threat that Obama says exists.  It doesn’t matter if Obama says he believes in whistle-blowers, even as he prosecutes more of them than all other presidential administrations combined. And it certainly doesn’t matter if he claims that no country would tolerate missiles being rained down upon them, while supporting the Israeli occupation of Gaza, and continuing to rain down missiles of our own, on the populations of countries we aren’t at war with.  It doesn’t matter, because no matter what evidence is produced, Democrats believe that Obama has good intentions, which far outweigh the actions of his policies.

Most of all, the faith one exudes in Obama rests upon the simple fact that he is our President, and that if he is assassinating people, it’s because those people without question were trying to do harm to the United States.  No evidence is needed.  No need to uphold the innocent until proven guilty mantra that we esteem and espouse in most criminal situations.  No need to provide any actual proof, that the “militant” in question is guilty of what our government says they are.  Even if the penalty for that accusation is death, and even if that death results in “collateral” damage- such as the deaths of innocent children.  No evidence is needed, even if the “militant” in question is an American citizen.  That is the very definition of faith, and it’s so extreme that it blinds us from acknowledging just how severe this assumption of power has become.

The audacity of the assumption that a Republican president would need “clear standards and procedures”, is embodied by what that statement implies:  That Obama feels the program he’s been running is indeed operating without “clear standards and procedures”, but that he believes he should be trusted with that lack of accountability.  Romney, in his view, could not be.  No clearer example for what Thomas Jefferson had in mind when he said, “In questions of power…let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution”, can be provided.  And yet this religious-like faith in Obama’s inherent goodness and right intent- despite the evidence to the contrary- persists.  Is it just partisan nationalism?  Could it be a continuation of the lesser of two evils rationale?  Or is it the unfounded belief that “we” are trustworthy, and “they” are not?

Perhaps the most telling line in the NYT story comes when the author admits that since Obama’s re-election, the “matter may have lost some urgency.”  This reaffirms my point.  Obama and his followers don’t feel that they require “clear standards and procedures.”  They believe that they can be trusted with vague and broad definitions of who constitutes a target, where that strike can occur, and what the legal consequences of such a strike might be.  They, and they alone, are responsible enough to determine when the loss of innocent life is worth the risk.  They are even bold enough to suggest that they can kill three American citizens, including a sixteen year old boy, and have the temerity to keep the citizenry in the dark.  Obama says, “trust me”.  The public doesn’t need to know how this process works.  It can rest assured, that it’s in good hands.  Sounds eerily like the faith argument we often hear from religious zealots.  And like that argument, evidence and reason are ignored every time.

Posted in Food For Thought | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment